The purpose of the current study was to compare and investigate the effect of fixed and individual valgus correction angle (VCA) on postoperative alignment restoration. It is hypothesized that individual VCA would be more accurate than fixed VCA in postoperative limb alignment restoration.
Four hundred and fifty-two patients with 546 consecutive uncomplicated primary total knee arthroplasties performed by a single surgeon, with 302 knees that had individual VCA (group A) and 244 knees that had fixed 5A degrees VCA (group B), were enroled in this study. Preoperative and postoperative full-length standing hip-to-ankle radiographs were used to assess limb alignment. Postoperative hip-knee-ankle angle (theta), femoral component angle (alpha) and tibial component angle (beta) were measured and compared between the two groups.
Mean postoperative theta angle and alpha angle were 178.9A degrees (SD 1.3A degrees) and 89.1A degrees (SD 1.1A degrees) in the group A, whereas they were 177.8A degrees (SD 1.9A degrees) and 87.9A degrees (SD 1.5A degrees) in the group B. There were significant differences in both parameters between the two groups (p = 0.021 and 0.016, respectively). Mean postoperative beta was 89.8A degrees (SD 1.2A degrees) in the group A and 89.7A degrees (SD 1.3A degrees) in the group B, and no significant difference was detected. There were 114 (37.7 %), 221 (73.2 %) and 265 (87.7 %) knees that had restoration of mechanical axis to +/- 1A degrees, +/- 2A degrees, +/- 3A degrees of neutral, respectively, and 37 (12.3 %) outliers (>+/- 3A degrees) in the group A, whereas there were 48 (19.7 %), 122 (50.0 %) and 170 (69.7 %) knees that had restoration of mechanical axis to +/- 1A degrees, +/- 2A degrees, +/- 3A degrees of neutral, respectively, and 74 (30.3 %) outliers in the group B. Group A had a higher percentage of restoration of limb alignment and fewer outliers than those in the group B, and this difference was statistically significant (p < 0.001).
The results from the present study demonstrated that individual VCA for distal femoral resection could enhance the accuracy of postoperative limb alignment restoration compared with fixed VCA. For clinical relevance, individual VCA should be recommended for routine use in all patients in order to achieve the expected postoperative neutral limb alignment and reduce the risk of postoperative malalignment due to the planning error of a fixed VCA.
Prospective comparative study, Level II.
Accession Number: WOS:000395078100040
Research Areas: Orthopedics; Sport Sciences; Surgery
Science Categories: Orthopedics; Sport Sciences; Surgery